Best Pizza in Palm Beach County: Where Locals Go for Authentic Slices (Part 1)

Let's be honest—finding truly exceptional pizza in Florida can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. But here in Palm Beach County, we've struck gold with so many pizzerias that rival the best pies from Chicago, New Haven, and New York City that we couldn't possibly feature them all in one article.

That's why we're launching this multi-part series to give each outstanding pizzeria the attention it deserves. Whether you're craving a four-pound Chicago-style deep dish that feeds the whole family, an authentic New Haven apizza with signature char, or a classic New York-style slice that folds perfectly—we'll cover every style and preference throughout this series.

In Part 1, we're featuring three distinctly different pizza experiences across Palm Beach Gardens, Delray Beach, and West Palm Beach—each representing a different regional pizza tradition. These aren't just our favorites—they're the spots where locals line up, families celebrate, and pizza lovers make special trips from across the county.

Future installments will explore wood-fired Neapolitan pizzerias, family-run Italian spots, creative specialty pizza shops, and more hidden gems across Palm Beach County. Don't worry—we'll make sure every pizza style gets its moment in the spotlight.

Ready to discover your new favorite pizza spot? Let's dive into Part 1's three outstanding pizzerias.

1. The Underground Pizza – Palm Beach Gardens

The Style: East Coast Deep Dish (Chicago-inspired)

If you've been missing authentic Chicago deep dish since moving to Florida, your search ends here. The Underground Pizza brings legitimate East Coast deep-dish pizza to Palm Beach Gardens, and locals can't stop raving about it.

Their signature pies feature a crispy cornmeal crust, rich tomato sauce, and generous layers of melted cheese—all baked in proper deep-dish style. The owner, Cole, has over 20 years of experience and you can taste it in every bite. This isn't some pale imitation; it's the real deal that Chicago transplants recognize immediately.

The Experience: Family-owned with a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for families and pizza lovers. The service is attentive, and you'll often meet Cole himself working as your server. Many reviewers say it's "worth the road trip" and "the best deep dish south of the Mason-Dixon line."

2. Ah-Beetz New Haven Pizza – Delray Beach

The Style: New Haven Apizza (Connecticut-style)

"There's no character without char!" is the motto at Ah-Beetz, and they mean it. Born in New Haven, Connecticut—the pizza capital of America—this South Florida favorite brings authentic apizza (that's "ah-BEETZ" in the local dialect) to Delray Beach.

What makes New Haven pizza special? It's that thin, crispy-yet-chewy crust with signature charred spots from coal and oak wood-fired ovens. The result is an unmistakable smoky flavor that pizza purists travel for. Even Barstool Sports' Dave Portnoy gave them an impressive 8.4 rating.

The Experience: Spacious and welcoming with a lively, family-friendly atmosphere. The dedicated team makes your visit memorable from the moment you walk in. Connecticut natives consistently say it's the real deal, and locals consider it "the best New Haven pizza in Florida."

Fun Fact: The Delray Beach location is their flagship, located in the Shoppes at Addison Place on Jog Road—conveniently close to Delray Marketplace for a full day out.

3. Bono Pizza & Pasta – West Palm Beach

The Style: Hand-Tossed New York-Style

Sometimes you just want a classic New York-style slice that folds perfectly, and Bono Pizza & Pasta delivers exactly that. This neighborhood favorite in West Palm Beach has earned a loyal following for making fresh, hand-tossed pizza the way it should be done.

Owner Boris and his team use only the finest Grande cheese and fresh ingredients daily. The result? Pizza that locals say "rivals those from New York and Chicago" with a perfectly balanced crust that's crispy on the bottom but not greasy, generous toppings, and sauce that tastes homemade (because it is).

The Experience: Warm, welcoming atmosphere with passionate service. Boris is known for his commitment to cooking delicious meals and building relationships with customers. Recent transplants and longtime residents alike call this their "regular Friday pizza spot" and say it's "maybe the best pizza and hero place in all of Florida."

Why Locals Love It: Beyond the excellent pizza, Bono offers full Italian cuisine including pasta, subs, wraps, and desserts—all with the same quality ingredients and care. It's become the go-to spot for families who want variety without sacrificing pizza quality.

Part 1 Complete—But Your Pizza Journey Is Just Beginning

From The Underground Pizza's legendary Chicago deep dish in Palm Beach Gardens to Ah-Beetz's authentic New Haven char in Delray Beach and Bono's neighborhood-favorite New York slices in West Palm Beach—these three pizzerias prove that Palm Beach County's pizza scene rivals the nation's best.

But here's the exciting part: this is just Part 1 of our comprehensive pizza series. We have so many outstanding pizzerias to feature across Palm Beach County that one article couldn't do them justice.

Whether you're a deep-dish devotee, a thin-crust purist, someone who loves creative toppings, or just wants a perfectly executed traditional slice—this series will guide you to the perfect pizzeria for every craving and occasion throughout Palm Beach County.

What pizza style should we feature in Part 2? Do you prefer wood-fired Neapolitan, creative specialty pies, or classic family-run Italian spots? We'd love to hear what you're most excited to see next in this series!

Here's to perfect crusts, authentic flavors, and many more pizza discoveries ahead,

— The Palm Beach Locals Team